The Quest For Sydney’s Best Cookies

By Sacha Barbour
30th Oct 2013

Whether it is paired with your afternoon latte or devoured as a sneaky midnight snack, there is something comforting about a scrumptious, crumbly biscuit.
From chewy choc-chip to crunchy peanut butter and gingerbread, we've got you covered, no matter what time of day your cookie craving hits.

Bondi Bikkies | Bondi

This Bondi store is spreading the cookie love far and wide, with handcrafted, homemade creations delighting patrons. At Bondi Bikkies, the muesli cookie is king and packed with fruit, seeds and cinnamon (and low in sugar!). Gluten-free treats are available here too—hoorah!

Cookies+Milk | Newtown

Step into this Newtown store and be transported to cookie heaven. Cookies of every kind are served up here—think jammy dodgers, gingerbread men, whoopie pies, macarons, lime and ginger yo-yos, and of course, classic chocolate. You can also get your hands on tarts, breakfast biscotti and savoury goodies. As it heats up, be sure to try their ice-cream sandwiches, which are served with Cookie+Milk's very own milk flower ice cream and two cookies of your choice.

West Juliett | Marrickville

This Marrickville cafe churns out tasty breakfast and lunchtime fare, but be sure to stop by for their mouth-watering cookies. The choc-chip creation is not your average biscuit; they are enormous, filled with melted chocolate chunks, and sprinkled with pink salt to balance out the sweetness. West Juliett regularly sell out of these tantalising treats, so head down early to avoid missing out.

Black Star Pastry | Newtown

Celebrated amongst the Sydney baking scene, Black Star Pastry are well known for their outstanding pastries and biscuits. The 'ginger ninjas' are a unique take on the gingerbread man and are sweet, crunchy and covered in milk chocolate. If you're looking for a more "grown-up" cookie, the Earl Grey macarons are truly life changing.

Flour and Stone | Woolloomooloo

Sweet bites are the name of the game at Flour and Stone in Woolloomooloo, and their cookies are top notch. They not only bake tasty varieties like Anzacs, peanut butter, and sour cherry, but also offer up vegan and gluten-free options too. Don't miss the wholesome rice malt bikkie—if you prefer your sweets guilt-free.

bills | Darlinghurst

Classic flavours abound at bills, with cookie options such as Anzac, chocolate chip and ginger nut served up as the perfect accompaniment to your afternoon coffee. If you're feeling like something a tad more indulgent, the passionfruit shortbread is the clear winner. Check out the Bills website for the Surry Hills location.

Mrs Fields | Around Sydney

Closing out our list of Sydney's tastiest cookies is an oldie but certainly a goodie. Established way back in 1977, you know the cookies from Mrs Fields have been tried and tested to perfection. Classic and sweet flavours are dished up alongside all the usual suspects, plus a few surprises; the snickerdoodle is a delectable creation with cinnamon and pure cane sugar. Mrs Fields signature giant cookie cakes are available in all your favourite picks, complete with iced designs and messages. Mrs Fields stores are scattered across Sydney; head here to find a store near you.
Image credit: Top With Cinnamon

Get our top stories direct to your inbox.

Unilever tracking pixel

Get our top stories direct to your inbox.

You May Also Like