Who’s The Best Joker Of Them All?

By Sophie Teague
29th Jan 2016


I think I should just state the obvious before you read on. I adore Heath Ledger. As soon as I laid eyes on that clean-shaven god from A Knight’s Tale, I was hooked. He was an Aussie dreamboat - and I made it my 12-year-old mission to watch every movie he ever made. And boy did I watch them ALL, including Candy when I was 14-years-old… yep, that taught me a lot of lessons.

I tell you this because I’m going to try my best to remain unbiased. I’ve taken my love away – as much as it hurts – and asked myself the ultimate question.

With Suicide Squad about to hit our screens, it's time to finally decide: Who’s the best Joker? Jack Nicholson, Heath Ledger or Jared Leto?

#3 Jared Leto

I feel bad for Jared because he’s on the back foot already - he has some pretty tough competition. To the credit of Suicide Squad creators they took their Joker in a different direction this time around: but I question if that was the right direction. Covered in tattoos and rocking a mean set of grills, Leto’s Joker is decidedly obvious.

Don’t get me wrong, on the surface he appears to fit the bill; an exciting mixture of insanity and charm that makes him equally as entertaining to watch than every Joker before him. It is, however, his general appearance that throws me off - it is total overkill. I mean, he has the word ‘damaged’ tattooed on his forehead and scribblings of ‘ha ha ha ha’ across his body...

Soz, Jared. I still love your luscious locks but you’ll have to take last spot for now.

#2 Jack Nicholson

Nicholson’s portrayal of our favourite comic-book villain is a playful, comical, and even campy interpretation. It feels like Nicholson’s Joker is trying to get the audience to laugh along with his cruel antics. Well, I guess he IS named the Joker after all... To Tim Burton’s credit, this is one of the closest depictions of the comic book character itself – a crazy clown reeking havoc on Gotham City. 

However, as we’ve moved through the decades, audiences seem to demand more than just a light-hearted, funny antagonist - now we want a truly creepy, gritty villain who shakes us to our core. This is why, albeit a brilliant performance, Nicholson must take second string to our man, Heath Ledger. I was scared of Nicholson’s Joker - but Ledger's was on the next level.

I'd rather take my chances with Nicholson's Joker rather than a cold, maniacal Ledger anyday. 

#1 Heath Ledger

Let’s be honest, we all knew we’d end up here. Truly the best Joker we have seen to date.

There was something different about Heath’s role: from the fantastic blotchy make-up to the greasy hair, two underrated creative decisions that established his instability as a character without being as blatantly obvious as tattooing 'damaged' on his forehead...

A lip-licking and lip-smacking maniac, Ledger injected a personality into the Joker that we had never seen before. Scarily, he was oddly likeable, whilst also remaining bloody well frightening. I don’t want to have to bring up the ‘pencil trick’ to remind you...

I’m sure it helped that Christopher Nolan’s reboot of the Batman franchise overall was a grittier, deeper and more realistic depiction than all of its predecessors – giving Ledger the perfect base to work from. But, Ledger’s performance is – in my opinion – flawless. I could watch him hang his head out of the police car all day, permanent goose bumps etched on my skin. Epic.

Photo credit: Suicide Squad

Want more movie arguments to initiate in the office? We make Love Actually and Home Alone face off in an epic battle of classic movies!

Get our top stories direct to your inbox.

Get our top stories direct to your inbox.

You May Also Like